| Definition | the Earth |
| OED requirements | antedating 1941 |
| Earliest cite | Edward E.Smith,'The Vortex Blaster' |
| Comment | Fred Galvin submitted a 1946 cite from George O. Smith's "Pattern for Conquest". Douglas Winston submitted a cite from a reprint of William Tenn's "Party of the Two Parts"; Mike Christie verified the cite in the 1954 first magazine appearance. Mike Christie submitted a 1949 cite from Poul Anderson's "The Double-dyed Villains". Malcolm Farmer submitted a cite from a reprint of Andrew Salmond's "Stimulus"; Mike Christie verified the cite in the 1958 original magazine appearance. Mike Christie submitted a 1942 cite from Ross Rocklynne's "Jackdaw". Mike Christie submitted a 1957 cite from Robert Heinlein's "Citizen of the Galaxy". Dan Tilque submitted a cite from a 1968 reprint of E.E. Smith's 1950 "Galactic Patrol"; Mike Christie checked the 1937/38 first magazine version and the cite does not appear there. Douglas Winston submitted a cite from a 1990 reprint of Michael McCollum's "Life Probe". Fred Galvin submitted a 1941 cite from Edward E.'Doc' Smith's "The Vortex Blaster". |
| Last modified | 6 July, 2008 |
click here for more information about the citation list
| 1942 R. Rocklynne Jackdaw in Astounding Sci. Fiction Aug. 68/2 | But where, in all the universes which stretched endlessly through the cosmos, had there been a precedent for the thoroughly confounding incidents which had occurred on Sol Three? |
| 1983 M. McCollum Life Probe xv. 237 | The Scientists and engineers of Sol III will have been drafted into the great effort. |